Q3: Interviews

What effect(s), if any, does the Office’s interview practice have on your decision to file an RCE?

Campaign: Q3: Interviews

The Pre-Exam Conference, Idea Further Elaborated

A couple points were brought out about a pre-Exam Interview concept, but may be buried in the comments or were in other discussions, so I just wanted to flush out the idea on its own. The idea is edited a bit, and additional points are listed below it: (To review: Before FAOM, if the Examiner feels that the claims are overly broad or contain a 112 error that would hinder prosecution, then the Examiner can call the ...more »

Submitted by

Voting

0 votes
0 up votes
0 down votes
Active

Campaign: Q3: Interviews

Quasi-Round of Prosecution by Enhanced Interview Procedure

A way to obtain the best of both worlds - a) the granularity of iterative prosecution and b) claim development without sacrificing official "rounds" of prosecution - is to expand the interview process. Currently, the time allotted to examiners for interviews is short (normally one hour including prep time), and the interview practice is very open-ended, but an interview can be enhanced into a quasi-round of prosecution ...more »

Submitted by

Voting

10 votes
10 up votes
0 down votes
Active

Campaign: Q3: Interviews

Provide Simple Pre-Search Interview Process

Examiners often seem to have only cursory understanding of invention before initial search. Often only until interviewing at second office action do they say "ah ha". Allow for simple pre-search interview---no onerous requirements, no discussion about prior art on the record. Simply present and explain the invention, invite examiner questions and examiner can ask 112 issues regarding the claims before the initial search. ...more »

Submitted by

Voting

3 votes
3 up votes
0 down votes
Active

Campaign: Q3: Interviews

effect of PTO interview practice on decision to file RCE

I think the PTO has directed examiner's to be fair and reasonable in allowing interviews after final rejections but they have made it almost impossible to reach an agreement on an amendment to overcome the rejection(s) because the examiners always say the amendment requires a further search or raises a new issue so you have to file an RCE to get the amendment entered (even if the examiner agrees that it overcomes the ...more »

Submitted by

Voting

1 vote
1 up votes
0 down votes
Active